Farmers in the region have rejected a report claiming
biofuels have pushed up food prices by 75pc.
A report by the World Bank says that production of crops like rapeseed and
sugar beet for fuel had had a major impact on global food prices. The
unpublished report, written by senior economist Don Mitchell, was leaked to
a national newspaper. A similar World Bank report, which was published in
April, also blamed biofuels for causing price rises but did not quantify the
claim.
The leaked report says “Without the increase in biofuels, global wheat and
maize stocks would not have declined appreciably and price increases due to
other factors would have been moderate.”
The study blames a tendency to use land to grow crops for biofuel rather
than food for a shortage, forcing prices skywards. It looked at a basket of
food and said prices rose by 140pc between 2002 and February this year. It
estimates that high energy and fertiliser prices only account for 15pc of
the increase, while biofuels caused them to jump by 75pc.
This contradicts claims by the US government that plant-derived fuel had
only increased prices by 3pc.
Farmers rejected the idea that growing crops for fuel could have such an
impact. John Collen, chairman of the National Farmers' Union in Suffolk, has
a cereal and dairy farm in Gisleham, near Lowestoft. He said the weather and
the cost of growing crops were to blame for shortages. “The shortage was
created by the bad weather in Europe but there's also been an exodus of
people planting crops in Europe because nobody could afford to grow them. My
costs for diesel and fertiliser have gone up threefold in a year.”
Mr Collen also said it was too soon to tell what impact biofuel would have.
He said: “It was in its first year last year and it is impossible to draw
that conclusion from one year's results, given that year had the worst
harvest in living memory.”
Alan Fairs grows oilseed rape for extra virgin oil and industry, but not for
biodiesel, in Heveningham, near Halesworth. He said he thought the claim was
“rubbish”. He said although the biofuels industry may have contributed to
food price rises, it was not the main factor and that a bad harvest and
production costs were mostly to blame. He said: “It's been one of those
years - seven years of plenty, seven years of famine. We had a terrible
year.”
But Rupert Read, from the Norwich Green party, said he was not surprised by
the report. He added: “We have been saying for years that biofuels are not
green and that they are going to have this terrible effect on the poor.”
Source:
Eastern Daily Press